Chieftain Car Insurance Review

3 minutes can save you hundreds. Enter your postal code below and join thousands of Canadians saving on car insurance.

Secure. No Spam. No Fees.

Why You Can Trust MyChoice

MyChoice serves as an independent intermediary between you, financial institutions and licensed professionals without any additional charge to our users. In the interest of transparency, we disclose that we partner with some of the providers we write about – we also list many financial services without any financial gain. MyChoice does not operate a financial institution or brokerage and to ensure accuracy, our content is reviewed by licensed professionals. Our unique position means that we hold no recurring stake in your policy, ensuring our mission to help Canadians make better financial decisions is free of bias or discrimination. 

Article Contents
Picture of By <span>Aren Mirzaian</span>
By Aren Mirzaian

Updated on March 12, 2025

Visit author page
Picture of By <span>Aren Mirzaian</span>
By Aren Mirzaian

Updated on March 12, 2025

Visit author page

2 minute read

Article Contents

This page is for informational purposes only. MyChoice is not affiliated with this company.

About Chieftain Car Insurance

Chieftain Insurance is a subsidiary of Travelers Insurance that offers car and home insurance in Ontario, Canada. The company primarily focuses on providing standardized basic insurance services at affordable prices. It also delivers continuous coverage and flexible payment models.

If you need a customized policy or more advanced auto-insurance coverage, Chieftain Insurance might not be the right company. But if you want basic auto insurance that’s easy to obtain and affordable, then you might be in the right place.

What sets Chieftain car insurance apart is its provision of continuous coverage. Your insurance policy will never expire and automatically renews at the end of a term. Of course, when you choose to terminate your policy, you can do it at no additional cost. Chieftain policies are also rated monthly, so your premiums are always up-to-date. For example, if your driving record improves, your monthly premium will decline the following month.

How Chieftain’s Customer Reviews Compare to Other Insurance Companies

Insurance
Provider
Company’s
Online Rating
Chieftain1.7/5
Dominion2.0/5
Western Assurance2.2/5
Pembridge1.7/5
PC4.5/5
Source: Google Reviews, Trustpilot

Why Choose Chieftain Car Insurance?

Sometimes, all you need is a basic insurance package that will meet the legal requirements of the land and get your car on the road. If you find most car insurance products confusing and have difficulty separating the substance from the sales pitch, Chieftain Insurance is an optimal option.

Chieftain’s auto-insurance policies provide essential coverage under the law and suffice for many customers with everyday policy needs. By delivering standardized coverage packages, Chieftain Insurance can also offer affordable coverage.

By selecting Chieftain Insurance for your car insurance, you will receive the following coverage:

  • Standardized insurance package for private-passenger cars
  • Up to $2 million in liability coverage
  • Improved accident benefits with higher limits for medical and rehabilitation care that you can increase further for an additional cost
  • Direct compensation for property damage, without deductibles
  • Coverage for loss of use
  • Liability coverage for damage to non-insured vehicles, such as rental cars
  • Family protection coverage
  • Waiver of depreciation

Chieftain Car Insurance Pros & Cons

Based on the company’s online reviews, below are some main pros and cons of getting car insurance with Chieftain.

ProsCons
Initial Low RatesFrequent Rate Increases
Immediate Rate Adjustments
for Convictions/Accidents
Poor Customer Service
Unexpected Policy
Cancellations
Difficult to Reach
Representatives

What Other Insurance Products Does Chieftain Offer?

Besides car insurance, Chieftain Insurance also provides home and condo insurance. Here again, the focus of the company’s policies is standardized basic coverage at affordable prices. If you need insurance to take out a mortgage from your bank and want to avoid all the hassles of choosing between hundreds of home insurance products, Chieftain might be the right choice for you.

Chieftain home and condo insurance policies include the following coverage:

  • Up to $2 million in liability protection
  • Protection for sewer backup, mass evacuation, and food in your freezers
  • Unlimited protection for computers and electronics, as well as fine art and silverware
  • “New for Old” replacement policy. Regardless of the age of the lost, stolen, or damaged item, Chieftain will replace it with a new, similar item.

When it comes to home insurance, Chieftain offers “Guaranteed Replacement.” So, if you lose your home to an accident or weather event, Chieftain pays the full cost of rebuilding it, regardless of your coverage limit. You can insure your property for up to 300% of its estimated replacement cost.

For condos, Chieftain coverage includes up to three times the policy limit for your share of the assessment in the case of a loss or damage to the common areas. Your policy limit also covers any improvements or additions to your condo unit. Chieftain also provides contingent insurance to bridge the gap between the coverage of your condo and the condominium corporation.

How To Get A Quote From Chieftain

To obtain a Chieftain car insurance quote, it’s easiest to go to their website or contact one of their advisors. MyChoice does not offer quotes from Chieftain.

It is important to remember that Chieftain Insurance offers policies only in Ontario. Travelers Insurance is a better choice for other Canadian territories.

How To Submit A Claim With Chieftain Insurance

Submit a claim through their website or contact one of their advisors.

Email

You can contact them at anytime 24/7

Contact by phone

Feel free to contact the team by phone

Website

File a claim by visiting the Cheiftain (Travelers) website

Congratulations! You made it to the end!

Now, here is the easy part: complete your quote in under 2 minutes

Discover More About Auto Insurance

Is Car Insurance More Expensive for Newer Cars?

Insurers typically set higher premiums for newer car models due to the high cost of repairing or replacing them after an accident. Read on to learn more.

OPCF 5 Endorsement Explained

OPCF 5 is an endorsement that protects the leasing company if your leased vehicle is damaged or lost. Read on to learn more about OPCF 5.

Trump Tariffs Will Shake Up Canada’s Insurance Market

Read our article to learn how Trump’s 25% steel and aluminum tariffs will drive up costs for Canadian insurers and policyholders.

Even More Ways To Save on Insurance